The Football Association has confirmed that Chris Kavanagh will take charge of the 2025 FA Community Shield match between Premier League champions Liverpool and FA Cup winners Crystal Palace, set for 10th August at Wembley Stadium. The appointment has sparked discussion among fans due to Kavanagh’s history with both clubs, particularly Liverpool, and his involvement in controversial moments last season. With Paul Tierney assigned to VAR duties, the officiating team is under the spotlight for this high-profile season curtain-raiser.
Controversial Decisions
Kavanagh, who last refereed Liverpool in the 2024 Carabao Cup final, a 1-0 victory over Chelsea at Wembley, is no stranger to high-stakes matches. However, his appointment has raised eyebrows among some Liverpool supporters, given his involvement in a controversial Merseyside derby last season. During that match, Kavanagh, with Tierney on VAR, failed to issue a red card to Everton’s James Tarkowski for a challenge on Alexis MacAllister, a decision that drew significant criticism.
Palace Perspective
Crystal Palace fans are likely to view Kavanagh’s appointment neutrally, as the referee has no significant controversial history with the club. However, the presence of Tierney on VAR, who was also involved in the Merseyside derby incident, could heighten scrutiny on the officiating decisions.
Views on Assistants
Kavanagh’s assistants, James Mainwaring and Wade Smith, bring additional experience to the match. Mainwaring, promoted to the FA’s elite list of referees and assistants last year, is a rising figure in officiating, while Smith has been a reliable presence in Premier League fixtures. Tony Harrington, the fourth official, has also officiated several high-profile games, ensuring a competent on-field team.
The inclusion of Paul Tierney as VAR is notable, given his involvement in last season’s controversial derby. Tierney’s decision-making from Stockley Park will be closely watched, especially after his failure to intervene in the Tarkowski incident. Liverpool fans, in particular, will hope for a performance free of controversy, as the Reds aim to kick off the season with a statement.
