In a dramatic twist on transfer deadline day, Marc Guéhi’s highly anticipated £35 million transfer from Crystal Palace to Liverpool has collapsed, leaving fans of both clubs stunned. The centre-back had already undergone a medical, and both clubs had submitted a deal sheet in hopes of extending the window to finalize the move. Despite the groundwork being in place, Palace ultimately refused to sanction the transfer.
🚨⚠️ BREAKING: Marc Guehi-Liverpool deal has COLLAPSED.
— Fabrizio Romano (@FabrizioRomano) September 1, 2025
Despite medical done and deal sheet submitted, Crystal Palace don’t approve the move following Igor deal off.
Guehi stays at #CPFC. 🦅 pic.twitter.com/xlfF2ap24T
The Breakdown: Why the Deal Fell Through
At the heart of the collapse was Crystal Palace’s inability to secure a replacement for Guéhi. The Eagles had been targeting Brighton defender Igor Julio, but the Brazilian travelled to West Ham for a medical instead.
Igor Julio is not going to join Crystal Palace as things stand, despite completing a medical there this afternoon 😮
— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 1, 2025
West Ham are now in talks with Brighton and the player to try to complete a deal to take him on loan ⚒ #DeadlineDay pic.twitter.com/ieyWO0Gljy
Palace manager Oliver Glasner made it clear that Guéhi would not be sold without a suitable replacement, emphasizing the defender’s centrality to the squad. With no viable alternative ready to step into Guéhi’s shoes, the club chose to retain their captain, ending Liverpool’s pursuit abruptly.
Implications for Liverpool
For Liverpool, the collapse is a significant setback. The club had agreed on personal terms with Guéhi and had lined him up as a critical piece of their defensive structure. The Reds now face uncertainty in shoring up their backline as the Premier League season progresses, particularly given their defensive struggles in recent campaigns. Richard Hughes and Arne Slot will now have to explore other options, but the closing of the transfer window limits flexibility.
Crystal Palace: Pressure to Strengthen
Crystal Palace, meanwhile, remain under pressure to strengthen their squad after already losing key players such as Eberechi Eze, who recently moved to Arsenal. Retaining Guéhi is a relief in terms of maintaining defensive stability, but the failure to bring in reinforcements exposes the Eagles to risk. The club must now scramble to secure signings before the window closes, all while ensuring that Guéhi remains motivated for the remainder of the season.
Guéhi’s Future: A Year Left on His Contract
Marc Guéhi’s personal situation adds another layer of complexity. The 23-year-old has one year remaining on his contract at Palace and had previously indicated that he would not extend it. While he remains with the club for now, uncertainty looms over his long-term future. Fans and pundits alike will be watching closely to see whether Guéhi will commit to Palace in the short term or continue to push for a move in the next transfer window.
The moral of the window, then: if you kick up enough of a fuss and sully your reputation at a club, you get what you want. If you do everything by the book with total respect for your club, you get screwed over. I feel for Marc Guehi tonight. Been denied a career-changing move.
— Lewis Steele (@LewisSteele_) September 1, 2025
Deadline Day Drama
This episode serves as a reminder of just how chaotic transfer deadline day can be. Deals that seem on the verge of completion can collapse due to timing, failed negotiations, or managerial insistence. For Liverpool, it’s a setback in their pursuit of defensive reinforcements. For Palace, it’s a reprieve—but one that comes with its own challenges.
As the dust settles, all eyes will remain on Guéhi and Crystal Palace. Will the defender channel his frustration into performances for the Eagles, or will another high-profile transfer saga unfold in the next window? Either way, today’s collapse has already left a mark on the Premier League’s summer narrative.