The 2025–26 Premier League season is barely underway, but Video Assistant Referee (VAR) has already stirred controversy, sparking debates among fans, pundits, and players alike. What is meant to bring fairness has, once again, fuelled frustration and divided opinion.
Chelsea vs Fulham: A Disallowed Goal Stirs Outrage
One of the latest flashpoints came during Chelsea’s clash with Fulham. Josh King appeared to score a legitimate goal, only for VAR to intervene and disallow it due to a perceived foul in the build-up. The decision sparked outrage, with Fulham manager describing it as “unbelievable” and fans taking to social media in frustration. The Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) later admitted the decision was inconsistent with VAR guidelines.
🗣️ "I think it's been too forensic."
— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 2, 2025
Dermot Gallagher on VAR's conclusion to rule out Josh King's opening goal against Chelsea 🔎 pic.twitter.com/DKlaVCYIYC
Manchester City vs Tottenham: Trafford’s Controversial Challenge
In another early-season incident, Manchester City goalkeeper James Trafford collided with Spurs’ Mohammed Kudus outside the penalty area. While some argued it should have been a red card for denying a clear goal-scoring opportunity, VAR upheld the referee’s on-field decision. The call prompted debates over VAR’s consistency and the interpretation of key rules.
Liverpool vs Bournemouth: Ignored Handball Controversy
Liverpool’s opening Premier League match against Bournemouth saw a striking example of VAR controversy. A Bournemouth player handled the ball on the halfway line during a critical counterattack, but VAR chose not to intervene. The decision left Liverpool fans frustrated, questioning whether the technology is applied fairly and consistently, even in clear-cut situations.
The VAR Debate: Fairness or Interference?
These incidents highlight the ongoing tension surrounding VAR. Supporters argue that it is essential for correcting major errors and ensuring fair outcomes. Critics contend that its inconsistent application disrupts the flow of the game, undermines referees’ authority, and leaves players and fans second-guessing every decision. Early reactions suggest the debate will only intensify as the season progresses.
Every intervention, overturned goal, or ignored incident this season is likely to spark discussion and analysis. VAR remains a powerful tool, but the question of whether it improves or complicates the game continues to divide the footballing world.
